The Miami Dolphins and the Kansas City Chiefs dismissed their head coaches—Tony Sparano and Todd Haley, respectively—on Dec. 12 with just three games left in the season, creating a puzzling question: Why now?
Despite their 4-9 record, the Dolphins are on an upswing, recovering from an 0-7 start to go 4-2 over the past six weeks. They’ll finish with a losing record and miss the playoffs this season, but that was pretty much a done deal at 0-7. With three games left in the season, what’s the point in firing Sparano now?
The Chiefs also got off to a slow start with three straight losses to open the 2011 season before ripping off four consecutive victories. However, Kansas City has lost five of its last six games and sits at 5-8 on the year. As with the Dolphins—perhaps even more so, since the Chiefs are technically still alive for a playoff spot, and Haley just led the Chiefs to the AFC West title last season—what’s the point in firing Haley now?
It’s a curious move by each team. Certainly, if management wasn’t happy with the coaches, the coaches should be removed, but in-season? And with just a few games left? That seems more disruptive than it’s worth. Just ride out the season and make a coaching change in a month or so.
I’m well aware that fans in Miami and Kansas City wanted Sparano’s and Haley’s heads on pikes a long time ago, but do those fans really think that Todd Bowles and Romeo Crennel—he of the 24-40 coaching record with the Cleveland Browns—are going to do any better the rest of the way? Even if they do, and the teams go 3-0 down the stretch, how is a 7-9 or 8-8 record going to help anyone? It would seem that at this point, moving up the draft order ladder would be more beneficial.
The Rationale
“The results speak for themselves,” said Dolphins owner Stephen Ross about Sparano’s termination. “We’re looking to becoming a winning organization, and I thought this was the best time to make the change and let us go in a direction that will allow us to become that.”
Uh huh. I guess I’m just not seeing how firing your head coach with three games left is going to point the team in the direction of becoming a winning organization.
“Timing in these situations is always difficult. There never seems to be a right time,” said Chiefs chairman and CEO Clark Hunt about Haley. “We just felt the inconsistent play the team has experienced throughout the season, including yesterday’s game, made today the right day to do it.”
Interesting. Have you seen the guys who are on your roster, Mr. Hunt? Or more accurately, have you seen the guys who aren’t on your roster?
The Chiefs
In Kansas City, the inconsistent play might be a result of season-ending injuries to starting quarterback Matt Cassel, starting running back Jamaal Charles, starting tight end Tony Moeaki, Pro Bowl defensive back Eric Berry, and linebacker Brandon Siler. Just a thought. It tends to put a damper on things when you lose all of those key positions to injury.
The Chiefs are left with Tyler Palko, who has been abysmal, at quarterback, but they made a shrewd move by picking up Kyle Orton off waivers after he was released by the Denver Broncos. Orton, however, lasted all of one play before he dislocated a finger in his throwing hand. Back to Palko went the Chiefs.
Kansas City certainly has room to improve, but given the rash of injuries at vital positions, coupled with Haley’s very recent success in the AFC West, his firing strikes me as throwing the baby out with the bath water.
The Dolphins
The Dolphins also lost their starting quarterback, Chad Henne, to a season-ending injury, and their second-stringer, Matt Moore, just got his bell rung and gave way to J.P. Losman in the team’s 16-point loss to Michael Vick and the Philadelphia Eagles. Prior to that, the team’s only loss in the past five games was by one point to the Dallas Cowboys on Thanksgiving Day.
Low home attendance figures seem to have contributed to Sparano’s demise, but Miami only has one remaining home game: January 1 against the New York Jets. Is firing Sparano now going to pack the house on New Year’s Day? I tend to doubt it.
If the rationale is that the Dolphins want to pursue a high-profile head coach like Bill Cowher, Jon Gruden, or Jeff Fisher, they certainly shouldn’t feel the need to dispose of Sparano first. After all, they publicly courted Jim Harbaugh in the off-season while Sparano was still in place. It doesn’t seem to bother the Dolphins organization at all to treat its head coach that way.
So I’m baffled by the timing. Why now?
Believe me, I understand wanting to see a head coach move on down the road. I’m a fan of the Indianapolis Colts. I probably don’t have to tell you how disastrous this season has been. Jim Caldwell can’t hit the bricks soon enough after the final gun on the season, as far as I’m concerned, but we’re well past the point of no return on the 2011 campaign. There is absolutely nothing to gain by firing Caldwell at this juncture. In fact, if you look at it through the Andrew Luck lens, there’s a lot to lose by winning our final three games.
Perhaps the Dolphins and the Chiefs will soon show me the light and I’ll see the error of my ways. But for now, I have a hard time understanding how the terminations of these two head coaches at this point in time is anything but detrimental to the teams.
The author is a Featured Contributor in Sports for Yahoo! Contributor Network. You can follow him on Twitter at @RedZoneWriting and on Facebook.
Also by this author:
Dallas Cowboys collapse in spectacular fashion against New York Giants
10 random thoughts about NFL’s Week 14
Orlovsky, Colts don’t enjoy return to Northeast
Note: This article was written by a Yahoo! contributor. Sign up here to start publishing your own sports content.
Thanks for visiting our blog =).